Clay Pigeons . The Boston Phoenix . 09-28-98

Clay Pigeons

DIRECTED BY: David Dobkin

REVIEWED: 09-28-98

The serial-killer genre offers new directors a kind of target practice: go for the easy marks and you can show off your fancy shooting. That's the case in David Dobkin's debut feature, a blithe homicidal romp set in backwoods Montana that hits the bullseye on charm, cleverness, sharp performances, and glib humor but misses the substance target altogether. The film opens with some desert shooting practice that goes terribly wrong, and soon Clay Bidwell (Joaquin Phoenix in a nice balance of innocence and venality) has more dead bodies than he can handle. He serendipitously pals up with easy-going Earl (huge baby man Vince Vaughn, whose ferocity is intensified by his softness); Earl proves more than a great fishing and drinking buddy, however, and through him Clay begins to confront his own darker nature. At least, he would had Dobkin learned more from his film's more mordant predecessors, Red Rock West and Blood Simple. Still, Pigeons is worth a shot, if only for the dyspeptic hilarity of Janeane Garofalo as an FBI agent.

--Peter Keough

Full Length Reviews
Clay Pigeons
Clay Pigeons
Clay Pigeons
Clay Pigeons

Capsule Reviews
Clay Pigeons

Film Vault Suggested Links
The Killing
Mulholland Falls
Double Indemnity

Rate this Film
If you don't want to vote on a film yet, and would like to know how others voted, leave the rating selection as "Vote Here" and then click the Cast Vote button.