Lisbon Story

The Boston Phoenix

DIRECTED BY: Wim Wenders

REVIEWED: 11-10-97

"Haven't been on the road for a while. Good," says Philip Winter (Rüdiger Vogler), the sound-man protagonist of Lisbon Story (at the Harvard Film Archive this weekend, November 7 and 8). Neither has the filmmaker, Wim Wenders, many of whose best pictures -- Kings of the Road, Alice in the Cities, Paris, Texas -- were old-fashioned, get-in-your-vehicle-and-drive movies. For the first minutes, as Winter tools from Berlin to Lisbon via Paris, Lisbon Story promises to be an exalted return to Wenders at his pre-Wings of Desire purest.

With Liza Rinzler's cinematography in the style of Wenders's '70s favorite, Robby Mueller, Lisbon Story starts as a thrilling montage of slices of highways, changes of skies, and shifts in weather, complemented by sound bites off the car radio of country-to-country music. Paris is the best: a one-second glimpse of the Eiffel Tower way at the end of a bicycle-lane-sized city street.

Then Winter drives into Portugal, his auto gets a flat tire, and Lisbon Story flattens out too, like a cold pancake. Winter has come to Portugal to reunite with filmmaker Friedrich Monroe, who has mysteriously run off. For a listless hour of Lisbon Story, Winter waits, picking up sounds in the city with his tape recorder, interacting with the neighborhood children. Never has actor Vogler been so annoyingly passive. The kids, talking incomprehensible pigeon English, are singularly uncharming.

More time is squandered with musical numbers by Madredeus, a just-okay Portuguese pop group. Then there's the ageless Manoel de Oliveira, Portugal's greatest filmmaker, who does a guest turn with a pompous philosophical monologue. Finally, Monroe (Patrick Bauchau) turns up, and it seems he's having an artistic crisis, unable to make films anymore. But Winter is there for an angel's pep talk: "Move your ass, finish your movie, with a little help from your friends."

The two characters are clearly Wenders in dialogue with himself, confessing his own filmmaking crisis in the '90s. But the sentimental "up" ending won't do. Lisbon Story shows, glaringly, that Wenders remains blocked.

--Gerald Paery

Capsule Reviews
Lisbon Story
Lisbon Story

Other Films by Wim Wenders
Buena Vista Social Club
The End of Violence

Film Vault Suggested Links
The Emperor's Shadow
Bent
Belle de Jour

Related Merchandise
Search for related videos at Reel.com
Search for more by Wim Wenders at Reel.com
Search for related books at Amazon.com
Search for related music at Amazon.com

Rate this Film
If you don't want to vote on a film yet, and would like to know how others voted, leave the rating selection as "Vote Here" and then click the Cast Vote button.