One seduction is executed in the opening moments of writer/director Paul
Thomas Anderson's Boogie Nights, while another has only begun. It
is 1977, and the disco scene is raging in the Me Decade. In the roaring
dimness of a dance club, a pornographic-film director sits with one of his
stars and takes notice of a handsome busboy. It's the adult film industry
version of discovery at Schwab's Drugstore. The filmmaker is Jack Horner
(Burt Reynolds), and his companion is Amber Waves (Julianne Moore). They
signal over a gorgeous blonde on roller skates (Heather Graham) and direct
her to gather information about the busboy. Her method is disarmingly direct:
Hi, would you like some oral sex? (I'm paraphrasing.) Who could resist?
Mission accomplished, Rollergirl reports back to Jack: The boy is endowed.
Jack makes the next contact himself. The lad is 17. His name is Eddie Adams.
Would he like a role in Jack's next film? Why, golly gee, sure. Eddie is
seduced by dreams of fame, and Anderson begins his seduction of his viewers.
We are watching people who earn their livings in the flesh trade, and by
generations of training in propriety, we are prepared to look down on them.
But by the end of this film, we will come to care about them a great deal.
Boogie Nights takes us on a voyage through the back streets of the
late 1970s and early '80s. Eddie changes his name to Dirk Diggler. And together
with co-stars Reed Rothchild (John C. Reilly), Amber and Rollergirl, Eddie
becomes the toast of the adult film industry. Action clips from a series
of his films look like bad Starsky and Hutch. (Yes, I know that's
redundant.) In them, Eddie stars as a secret agent named Brock Landers who
beats up bad guys and saves the world as he beds all the beauties along
the way. Interesting, isn't it, how close that description comes to capturing
the long James Bond series. Is it just a matter of where you put the camera
when you shoot the sex scenes?
Eddie and his pals get rich. Eddie buys himself a red Corvette, a fancy
pad and furnishings that make us hold our sides laughing. Before we get
too smug, though, we need to remember what Graceland looks like. And Elvis
is a god, isn't he? As with Elvis, things go bad after a while. Too little
discipline, too much dope. Elvis turned his head, and his audience was stolen
by the Beatles and the Rolling Stones. Eddie gets sloppy, and pretty soon
the naked guy in front of the camera goes by the name of John Doe (Jonathon
Quint). In fleshpot Hollywood, as in the mainstream, what goes up must come
down.
There's so darn much to like about this movie. It is notable, first of all,
for its firm determination to avoid being judgmental. Boogie Nights
is neither a champion of the pornographic film industry nor its self-righteous
accuser. The characters the film situates in the industry are mostly damaged.
Eddie comes from a horrible lower-middle-class home with a vicious mother
and an impotent father. Rollergirl is a high-school dropout. Amber is a
divorced mother who has lost a custody battle with her cold ex-husband.
A black performer named Buck Swope (Don Cheadle) has turned to porn because
of the dearth of decent roles for black actors. In one fashion or another,
all these folks are looking for a family. Some troubled souls in our society
turn to religious cults; these people find an oddly nurturing community
in the adult film industry.
But just as Anderson probes the scandalous to find the human dimension at
its core, he refuses to romanticize and, in that manner, to patronize his
characters. Eddie is an innocent (his last name isn't Adams by accident).
And he's actually quite nice, as illustrated by his relationship with Scotty
(Philip Seymour Hoffman), the homosexual sound man. But Eddie's not exactly
the brightest bulb in the lamp. In the film's sober denouement, we can see
the extent to which life has reduced him to his own sexual member. Amber
really does care for Eddie, and there's no question that her maternal instincts
are both strong and genuine. But she's a contemptible jerk for turning Eddie
on to cocaine. Jack readily plays father to Eddie and Rollergirl both, but
his dreams of genuine artistic achievement are laughable. He means what
he says, but his coarse exegesis on art porn is a howler. When Jack studies
footage of his latest skinflick and waxes ecstatic about what he has wrought,
we can't help but think of his nursery-rhyme namesake's penchant for self-congratulation.
And, in addition, Anderson recognizes that the adult film business is a
magnet for legitimate creeps. The man who bankrolls Jack's films is busted
for kiddie porn, something Anderson obviously does condemn.
Anderson's script is endlessly inventive and far more interested in complexity
of characterization than in forthrightness of theme. But he has points to
make. One can't help but reflect that the various debauches of the '70s
gave way to the cultural backlash of Reaganism in the '80s. The character
of Little Bill (William Macy) may be seen as an emblem of this transformation.
He works in the pornographic film industry, but he's incensed at the sexual
licentiousness of his wife (real life porn star Nina Hartley). His wife's
thoughtless behavior is wrong, but Little Bill's responding violence on
New Year's Eve 1979 is not an appropriate response.
Elsewhere, issues such as race bubble up with great subtlety. Both Buck
and the black female star, Becky Barnett (Nicole Ari Parker), seem to have
arrived on the porn scene for slightly different reasons than their white
counterparts, and both try to escape to notably unglamorous places. Becky
moves off to Bakersfield with a man who manages an auto parts store. Buck
strives to realize a dream of owning his own audio equipment outlet. Moreover,
it is fascinating to note that the problems the picture's characters encounter
are not the direct by-products of having sex on film. AIDS is never introduced,
for instance, nor are any other sexually transmitted diseases. Neither is
sexual jealousy among the performers ever a problem. Rather, trouble stems
from that traditional host of vices, including greed, vanity, faithlessness
and various forms of excess. It is clear that Anderson is not out to automatically
censure people who appear in and make sexually explicit films, but he is
ready to condemn drug abuse, infidelity and violence.
Boogie Nights' dialogue recalls Kevin Smith's Clerks and Quentin
Tarantino's Pulp Fiction. It is casually explicit and riotously funny.
In one segment, Eddie drives us into the aisle with laughter as he holds
forth on pornography and the lessons of history. And Reed splits our sides
with his ridiculous self-assurance as he contemplates what life would be
like if he weren't a porn star: "I'd just have sex on my own time."
Funny and imaginative as this movie is, it finally triumphs over a work
like Pulp Fiction because of its heart. Tarantino is a terribly clever
writer, but he has yet to make us care about the people in his movies. We
absolutely do care about the characters we meet in Boogie Nights.
They make a living in a manner that makes most of us at least a little squirmy.
But they need what all of us need: acceptance, respect, tenderness, friendship
and, after they've gone astray, forgiveness.