In what is at once the funniest and most disturbing scene in Ang Lee's
magnificent The Ice Storm, two New England teenagers stumble toward a
sexual experience, although it's not clear that either really wants to. The
girl is 14, the boy is 15, and they've petted previously but never with much
urgency and always, it seems, without even a trace of pleasure. As the
youngsters almost numbly negotiate who will now touch whom and where and for
how long, the girl suddenly finds a Nixon mask, which she slips over her head.
Negotiations continue until clothes are unbuttoned and the boy is lying between
the girl's jeans-clad legs. And all the while, she leaves the Nixon mask on.
The scene reverberates with symbolism, of course. It is 1973, and the chilled
gray weather, the messy den, the children joyless in their sex play and the
haunting visage of America's most disreputable president all conjure a nation
that has sacrificed its soul on the altar of material prosperity and
self-indulgence.
Adapted from Rick Moody's novel, The Ice Storm is the story of two
1970s families in New Canaan, Conn., and by extension their entire suburban
community and even America as a whole. Both fathers, Ben Hood (Kevin Kline) and
Jim Carver (Jamey Sheridan), are prosperous businessmen who have been able to
provide their families wonderful, spacious homes situated on huge, tree-shaded
lots. Neither Ben's wife, Elena (Joan Allen), nor Jim's wife, Janey (Sigourney
Weaver), works, but both are discontent, though in different ways.
Sixteen-year-old Paul Hood (Tobey Maguire) attends an elite prep school in New
York City. His sister, Wendy (Christina Ricci), attends school in New Canaan
along with Mikey (Elijah Wood) and Sandy (Adam Hann-Byrd) Carver. The two
families are next-door neighbors, and their lives are intertwined in a number
of ways. Ben is having an affair with Janey; Wendy is the girl in the Nixon
mask, Mikey her partner. This is the time of waterbeds, leisure suits, flared
pants and moral rot. The Hoods and the Carvers have everything they could
conceivably want except a sense of purpose. Then on a late fall night when the
Connecticut coast is rocked with the worst ice storm in a generation, the
children slip away when they're supposed to stay home, and the parents go to a
key party, a polite name for a wife-swapping lottery.
Extracting Moody's rich detail, screenwriter James Schamus and director Lee
have crammed this film with meaning. Nothing is random. All text points to
subtext. Nixon sweats and prevaricates from every TV screen. Parents cheat.
Wendy steals candy. Paul smokes dope in his dorm room. Mikey and Wendy pig out
on junk food. Though she hardly needs to, Elena shoplifts makeup from the local
drugstore. The world is full of dishonesty and disloyalty. Whereas only a
half-generation earlier, friendship meant steering clear of a pal's girl,
Paul's prep school roommate routinely strives to score with any girl Paul finds
attractive. Such is the final result of the sexual revolution. Friendship has
become much less important than sexual conquest.
Sex, of course, is a central issue here. But all the magic, all the warmth,
all the personal elements have been stripped away. Janey and Ben couple on a
gray afternoon while Elena runs errands. But their sex has all the heat of
Jello. At some point, there is presumably a spasm of physical pleasure, but no
connection is made. Janey could just as well be using a stud service.
Afterwards, when Ben tries to talk about a concern at work, Janey chides him
for boring her. Often, we gather, and perhaps not to soil sheets on which Jim
will later sleep, Janey and Ben copulate in Sandy's bedroom. The coolness of
their illicit union is reflected in the sexual experimentation of their
children. They are all looking for something they're clearly not finding in the
Pandora's box of the new sexual freedom.
Elena knows what's going on between Ben and Janey, and at first she turns,
haltingly, to the church. We learn that she's attended services recently but
hasn't continued. And no wonder: the pastor has hair down to his shoulders and
speaks in phrases as hip as his outfits. God has become as passe as '50s
haircuts. Pastor Philip Edwards (Michael Crumpsty) seems more interested in
becoming Elena's lover than her spiritual counselor. He doesn't seem to have a
wife, but that doesn't keep him from showing up at the key party. Repelled but
directionless, Elena tries to cope by regressing. She envies her 14-year-old
daughter and takes to riding a bicycle. Jim makes a comparably adolescent
response. He runs away from home, figuratively if not literally. He spends days
at a time on business trips, but he's so disconnected from his family that his
sons don't realize when he's gone. Eventually, Elena and Jim draw together in
sad desperation and resort, like teenagers, to sex in a car.
In a series of images, Lee reminds us of ice's brittleness. Under sudden
pressure, it shatters like glass. Drain a family of its warmth, and it cannot
hold together. Janey has become so cold in her pursuit of impersonal pleasure
that her family is poised to fragment. She moves from a neighbor's husband to
another's young adult son. And though she exhibits at least superficial
concerns for her children, they are withering in the frost. Bright, handsome,
likable and athletic, 15-year-old Mikey uses drugs and escapes into distracted
vacancy. Sandy seems even more lost. Lonely and aimless, he blows up all his
toys with firecrackers. Questioned about it by Wendy, he shares his fantasies
of the treasure of new toys he'll get a few weeks hence at Christmas, new toys
he looks forward to destroying in fantastic new ways. Perfunctorily performing
her maternal duties, Janey directs Sandy to make noise with a whip instead of
cherry bombs, whereupon, left unsupervised as always, Sandy begins to whip the
blossoms off a large potted hibiscus. The ultimate price of Janey's chilly
negligence will be tragedy, though it's unclear there's enough heart left in
her to long care.
Bleak as all this sounds, however, Lee insists on the possibility of
redemption. The only real sexual urgency portrayed in the entire film rises
between Ben and Elena, husband and wife coupling in the afternoon like the
lovers they once were. Perhaps they can stop their slide down the icy slope of
self-indulgence. Perhaps their children can be saved. Ben insists that Paul
come home for a family meal at Thanksgiving. Before dining, Ben invites his
daughter to say grace. And even though the room is filled with tension and
faintly concealed acrimony, there's a residual of love there as well. Things
have gone bad between Ben and Elena. But there was obviously once something
better, something that might be rediscovered and nursed back to health.
Ben and Elena aren't providing the discipline and the nurturing that their
children need, but they've instilled in Paul and Wendy something essential:
brother and sister clearly love each other. Whereas Mikey and Sandy seem
hollow, Paul and Wendy exhibit a moral core. Wendy waxes indignant at Nixon's
clumsy cover-up of despicable crimes. Oddly, we can even see her core of
decency in the sex games she plays with Sandy, whom she treats with great
gentleness and evident concern. Sandy is still just a little boy, and she
wishes to be just a little girl with him. Her shocking overture, "You show me
yours, and I'll show you mine," is the challenge of a grade school child, not
an invitation to sexual contact. Wendy yearns for that earlier time when Ben
and Elena acted like adults, and after she's caught in a sexual act with Mikey,
she wants her father, literally, to carry her home.
Paul shows a comparable substance. He remains a virgin in an atmosphere of
rampant teenage sexual activity. And though he has a boy's natural hunger for
sexual experience, he wants that something more that involves interacting with
a person and not just the interplay of sexual organs. He's grown fond of a
bright classmate named Libbets Casey (Katie Holmes), but when she overindulges
in alcohol and drugs one night (activities he's tried to dissuade), he refuses
to take advantage of her. Instead, he returns home to his family, striving to
keep his curfew. He is caught in the ice storm, but he makes it home where all
the members of his family await his return in the rising light and gradual thaw
of a new day. Hope springs eternal. The Ice Storm is that rarest of
recent cinematic creatures -- an American movie that dares to think of itself
as a work of art.