In films like Alien
and Thelma & Louise, director Ridley Scott has made
his female leads into legends. These women are tough, strong,
and, if need be, deadly. It's in this line that he brings in Demi
Moore as Jordan O'Neil, a woman who shows enough mettle to bite
through steel.
In G.I. Jane,
O'Neil is the guinea pig of Senator Lillian DeHaven (Anne
Bancroft). DeHaven bullies the Navy into taking O'Neil as a SEAL
recruit in order to put herself in the record books. If O'Neil
fails -- like 60 percent of the all-male SEAL recruits do --
well, at least she tried.
What DeHaven and O'Neil's superiors and
peers aren't prepared for is that she doesn't just try, she
succeeds. She makes it through the horrifically grueling rigors
of multilevel training despite the distrust and animosity of some
of the men and without (for the most part) gender-based aid or,
it seems, the added support of a sports bra.
The screenplay, written by Danielle
Alexandra and David Twohy, doesn't have much to it. Basically,
it's Demi playing war. O'Neil is put through a series of tests --
she pulls a boat, gets tortured, eats from a garbage can -- so
that the audience is compelled to root for her. Her main obstacle
is Master Chief John Urgayle (Viggo Mortensen), a man so menacing
that the music slows down each time he enters a scene. But there
is no question of her gutting it out and coming out of the ordeal
a well-respected hero ("I'd go to war with you
anytime"). The only real bit of intrigue is exactly when
she'll get around to shaving her head.
There is, of course, more to this part
than Moore's bald head. She is up to this very physically
demanding role, and she should be commended for meeting the
challenges of it. And while she does bare a little flesh, there's
nothing overtly sexual about it. From her one-handed push-ups to
her barking back at the men, she is in control and she carries
the film.
And though this movie is about a woman
reaching a goal, G.I. Jane, unlike Thelma & Louise,
should not be construed as a female-power film. Her struggle is
about survival of the fittest. This is made plain by three words
spoken by O'Neil -- words that become sort of the mantra for the
movie -- "Suck my dick." With these words any bigger
meaning this film holds about the force of women crumbles.
Certainly O'Neil could have picked something just as crude to
say, such as "Get ready to dig my combat boot out of your
rear." What these words mean is that O'Neil has become fully
assimilated -- she is a lean, mean fighting machine.
Infertility is no laughing matter. It is
especially no laughing matter when it comes to A Smile Like
Yours, the new romantic comedy starring Greg Kinnear and
Lauren Holly.
Kinnear and Holly play Danny and
Jennifer Robertson, a very happily married couple. Danny is a
successful elevator contractor, while Jennifer co-owns a boutique
and dabbles in perfume-making. Their m.o. for remaining tight is
to have sex all the time, everywhere, particularly in public. The
only hitch in the Robertsons' bliss is that there are no
children. Danny takes the no-fuss, it-happens-when-it-happens
approach to parenthood. Jennifer, on the other hand, is more
active and more covert.
Jennifer stops taking the pill, but
after months and months of negative pregnancy tests, she grows
concerned. She visits her family doctor, who tells her he needs
to test Danny. Knowing her husband's feelings about the matter,
Jennifer circumvents Danny's involvement until she has no further
choice but to drag him to a fertility clinic.
As they go through the various processes
involved at the clinic, Danny receives a tempting proposition to
work on a project in Seattle, a project that is headed by a dishy
architect (Jill Hennessy), who is interested in more than Danny's
elevators. Meanwhile, Jennifer strikes gold when one of her
perfumes has a big cosmetic company knocking at her door. These
situations and Jennifer's sneakiness spell trouble and hurt
feelings, posing a threat not only to the couple's babymaking,
but to their marriage as well.
It is possible to sit through this movie
without cracking a smile. Director and co-screenwriter Keith
Samples, making his directorial debut after producing such films
as Big Night, 2 Days in the Valley, and Kingpin,
has come up with a film that is totally bland. The relationship
between Jennifer and Danny is presented in an overly cutesy
light. While both Holly and Kinnear are likeable enough, there is
absolutely zero chemistry between them. Holly is stiff in this
role, and Kinnear, though more at ease, is given no opportunity
to demonstrate the charisma that made him famous.
The only marginally funny moment is when
Danny's best friend, Steve (Jay Thomas), explains the real
horrors of fatherhood. The talented Joan Cusack, who plays
Jennifer's business partner, is completely wasted. Mostly, the
gags thud. At the fertility clinic, Danny is led to a room called
the "Masturbatorium," while Jennifer hallucinates that
she is being prodded by terrifically huge gynecological
instruments.
As romantic comedies go, A Smile Like
Yours is barren.
--Susan Ellis
Full Length Reviews
G.I. Jane 
G.I. Jane 
Capsule Reviews
G.I. Jane 
Other Films by Ridley Scott
The Duellists 
Film Vault Suggested Links
Men With Guns 
Lamerica 
Animal Farm 
Related Merchandise
Search for related videos at Reel.com
Search for more by Ridley Scott at Reel.com
Search for related books at Amazon.com
Search for related music at Amazon.com
Rate this Film
If you don't want to vote on a film yet, and would like to know how
others voted, leave the rating selection as "Vote Here" and then click the
Cast Vote button.
|