In one of the many characteristics Palmetto
borrows from classic film noir, we occasionally hear voice-over narration from the
seriously flawed hero, Harry Barber (Woody Harrelson). In the scene in which Harry feels
the undercurrent of a get-rich-quick scheme pulling him from the shoals of his amoral
opportunism out into the depths of really big trouble, he muses: Over and over I
told myself I shouldve just pulled out then and there.
The line will take on a special resonance
for anyone managing to sit through Palmetto.
Of all the teeming hordes of misconceived
noir spawn in recent years, this, we might hope, is the worst, the one that will shake
even the appalling taste and failed imagination of Hollywood by the shoulders and say: No
more. All of us who know and love real film noir should start a letter campaign; we could
use the classic Lloyd Bentsen line from the 1988 vice-presidential debate I
knew film noir. It was a friend of mine. And this Tarantinoesque twaddle is not film
noir.
Director Volker Schlondorff has been able
successfully to deploy elements of noir in other contexts: The Tin Drum and A
Handmaids Tale place ordinary protagonists in extraordinary situations and foment a
heightened sense of ambient paranoia, corruption, and psychic claustrophobia. With
Palmetto, however, Schlondorff seeks to immerse himself in the genre itself. The result
doomed from the outset by an abysmal script and the casting of Harrelson is
a reverential survey of film-noir technique, from rain-splashed windshields in the night,
to high-contrast light and shadows (including even the requisite window blinds), violence,
and cheap sex. Its all there. But it never simmers.The characters are utterly
uninteresting, and the situations are so heinously derivative of scores of other better
movies that, at best, Palmetto feels like a rather boring parody, a sort of
Forbidden Noir revue.
Elisabeth Shue is wasted in a small, inane
role, about which she seems embarrassed. (She should be.) And Harrelson is simply out of
his element trying to portray a man scrambling on the slippery slope of a moral quagmire;
he simply doesnt look like a man who would be aware of such a dilemma. The rivulets
of sweat that trickle down his face from the beginning of the film to its end have more
energy than his performance and are about as interesting to watch.