Oprah Winfrey isn't the best thing about Beloved, a viscerally
moving film whose deep and original vision builds from the foundation of
Toni Morrison's novel. Nonetheless, Winfrey's involvement, both as star and
through her production company Harpo Films, makes her the architect of its
greatest accomplishment. Winfrey's presence legitimized the film as
authentic black self-expression, which took away the onus of hiring a white
male urbanite, Jonathan Demme, to direct this story about rural black
women.
And make no mistake: Jonathan Demme's startling and beautiful
interpretation of the story is the best thing about Beloved.
He infuses it with themes that arise from potent images, and he transforms
strands of meaning only suggested in the script into rich veins of
cinematic emotion. If he couldn't mine greatness from every script page,
then at least he constructs a space where Morrison's genius can flower on
the screen, fertilized by his reimagination of the boundary lines between
life and death, human and animal, present and past.
Beloved tells the story of Sethe (Winfrey), a former slave who
escaped from Kentucky to Ohio with her children but without her husband.
After she moves into her mother-in-law's home on the outskirts of
Cincinnati, a series of deaths rocks the household, and an angry spirit
plagues the house with poltergeist-like manifestations, driving Sethe's two
sons away. In 1873, as the movie's main action begins, one of Sethe's
Kentucky acquaintances shows up on her doorstep and finds her living with
her teenage daughter Denver (Kimberly Elise) in virtual isolation from the
community that passes daily outside their door. Paul D. (Danny Glover)
moves in and finds work, but the family's relative stability is soon
disrupted by a strange visitor, a young woman who can barely speak or walk
but who calls herself "Beloved." Her arrival at first delights the
friendless Denver, but gradually it becomes clear that the stranger has
crossed a greater divide than the Ohio River on her journey to Sethe's
home.
It takes almost three hours to tell the whole story of Beloved's nature
and the significance of her visitation, and in some ways the movie's
unusual length is appropriate. Beloved moves all its characters
through big changes, and it's necessary to develop their starting points in
this drama deliberately. Otherwise, their subsequent journey might seem
arbitrary.
But a feature-length movie, even a long one, can't take a novel's care
in this regard. That's where Demme's command of cinematic shorthand works
wonders. At one point, Demme compresses the arduous task of stage-setting
and characterization into a series of short, incidental scenes that show
the family's new routine after Beloved's arrival. This technique--scenes of
30 to 60 seconds separated by quick fades to black--approaches cinematic
pointillism, and it rapidly conveys the fluidity of the family's dynamics
under unusual stress.
However, such innovation can only be a transitional device, moving us
from the pre- to the post-Beloved situation. Before and after these
riveting, rhythmic moments, the movie sometimes bogs down in more
traditional expository scenes. Sethe and Paul D. have slow, tortuous
conversations, which are serious, full of stagy pauses, and unrealistically
revelatory. The one quality of Beloved that needs improvement is its
attachment to heartrending and tragic monologues. Not only would stoic
understatement be more effective, it would also ring truer for these
characters, who have survived by putting their pain in the past.
Whether conscious forgetting is a good strategy for dealing with the
inconceivable brutality of Sethe's slave days, however, becomes a key issue
in the film. Sethe is determined, at all costs, to protect her daughter
from the life she fled 18 years before, and the film echoes her consistent
denial by refusing to give its audience backstory. Names, places, and
events are thrown around for two hours of screen time before Sethe and the
script break down and tell us who and what they are--and what happened to
them. My screening was full of whispers as people asked each other what
these cryptic references were all about, afraid they'd missed something. Be
patient: Beloved structurally reenacts Sethe's defense against her
unbearable past until at last she is forced to tear down that final
wall.
Beloved argues that the dividing line between past and present is
artificial, a human construct. So, too, with the dividing line between
civilization and nature. Demme picks up on two clues in the movie's
script--a slaveholder's discourse on the animal nature of blacks, also a
stump preacher's admonition to black folks to love their own flesh--and
conceives a radical connection between the natural world and human society.
So close are the two, the director suggests, that the dead can reenter the
human sphere by traveling through the forms of life that emerge from the
earth where they are buried. From the grave to the grass to the insects to
human flesh--real, solid, black flesh--is a conceivable route back to life
in the continuity Demme envisions. Tak Fujimoto's elegiac, starkly sensual
images of butterflies, foxes, water, and tree leaves reinforce this
beautiful reversal of the slaveholder's accusation. "Animal" is no longer
an insult, and the love of flesh, for all its dangers, becomes the purest
form of spirituality.
Demme has been working below his potential in the past decade, although
he has been rewarded by Oscar voters for high-profile films like The
Silence of the Lambs and Philadelphia. With Beloved, his
keen eye and philosophical mind return with a breadth of vision that
reinforces the novel's best insights. Yet his persuasion is so quiet, and
his humanistic concern for his actors (especially Kimberly Elise in her
triumphant third-act maturation) so great, that audiences may leave
Beloved without any awareness that a hand other than Winfrey's is
guiding the camera lens. In a sense, they're right: Winfrey has guided
attention away from the director in the best possible manner, leaving him
free to tap the naked power of cinema to create and connect.