The story of Cinderella has been the basis for movie screenplays since
the days of the silents because it has a truly timeless theme. After all,
love between members of different social strata will be around as long as
the class system itself endures. But the problem with making a movie based
on Cinderella is how to keep it fresh. Ever After: A Cinderella
Story takes the novel tack of trying to imagine a realistic genesis for
the Cinderella myth, and as long as it avoids the temptation to update the
old story with contemporary attitudes, it's a uniquely satisfying version
of the tale.
Anachronisms, however, cannot help but creep in from time to time,
especially since that California chick Drew Barrymore is asked to play
Danielle, a French country girl of the 16th century. After her father's
death, Danielle has been relegated to a servant's role by the Baronness
(Anjelica Huston), who is angling her snooty daughter for marriage to
Prince Henry (Dougray Scott). But the prince gets an eyeful of Danielle, in
disguise as a courtier, and an earful of her liberal theories on
noblesse oblige. With the help of Leonardo da Vinci, improbably at
court as a visiting genius, Danielle seeks to overcome royal prejudice and
the schemes of her stepmother.
It's hard to get beyond Barrymore's game but misguided attempt at an
accent not a French accent, of course, but the English accent that passes
for generic European in American movies. She seems to be doing an Emma
Thompson impression punctuated by violent head bobs and shakes to help her
concentration. If this distraction can be ignored for a moment, lots of
truly talented actors are doing great work in Ever After. Scott is
more than just a princely, pretty face; he has a regal manner and a nicely
self-deprecating sense of humor. Melanie Lynskey, as the dowdy stepsister
Jacqueline, parries the insults of the Baronness with a sly wit. And Huston
plays off the evil stepmother cliché with wicked glee, although the
comeuppance awaiting her at movie's end is a bit strong, given that the
script encourages us to feel some sympathy for her.
The real achievement of Ever After is how it fills out the
Cinderella plot with enough detail to keep our attention and even surprise
us once or twice. Settings, costumes, and historical tidbits give the movie
sensuality and at least the illusion of smarts. If Barrymore had been
replaced by a more believable performer, and if a few other loose ends had
been cleaned up, it might have been an unqualified success. Even in its
flawed state, it will awaken romance in the heart of any girl over the age
of 8. Ignore the incomprehensible PG-13 rating, and take the preteens but
be prepared for their disappointment when Sir Thomas More's Utopia
doesn't prove quite as accessible as Danielle makes it sound.