French director Catherine Breillat's film Romance has caused a
mild sensation on both sides of the Atlantic. But it's unlikely to cause
much of a stir here in Nashville--because it's unlikely to make an
appearance in any local theater, chain or otherwise. The film has no MPAA
rating, but it would be a clear NC-17 because of the presence of several
explicit--some might say pornographic--sex scenes. Which means that
Nashville cinemas won't touch it, and local filmgoers with an interest in
mature subject matter will have to settle for Deuce Bigalow: Male
Gigolo.
The weird thing is, though, what would be likely to shock audiences in
Romance is what happens amongst all the clinical copulation. In one
sequence, the film's lead character, Marie (played by Caroline Ducey),
sneaks out of the bedroom of her model-boyfriend Paul (Sagamore Stevenin).
She picks up a man in a cafe, makes out with him in her car until morning,
makes a date to meet later for sex--and then drives straight to her job as
a grammar school teacher.
Romance is not necessarily about the distance between our sex
lives and our "normal" lives, but it's not not about that either.
The film is a sometimes harsh, sometimes arousing (in more ways than one)
look at one woman's sexual dysfunction, and by extension--Breillat would
likely assert--all women's.
Saddled with a sexy boyfriend who won't sleep with her, Marie endeavors
on a series of increasingly degrading affairs. With the stranger from the
cafe, Marie attempts to see if she can make sex disgusting to a man by
constantly referring to human hair, blood, and semen. She fails to turn him
off. Later, Marie allows herself to be stripped and tied up by her boss,
then proceeds to sell herself to a man on the street, who essentially rapes
her without paying her. Marie is undeterred. She defiantly shouts after
him, "I'm not ashamed!"
Ultimately, Marie gets pregnant and allows herself to be a case study
for gynecology students. They stand in line with their plastic gloves,
awaiting a turn at the exam table. The story, and all lingering eroticism,
ends with a nothing-taboo depiction of live birth.
Because this is a French film, the scenes of graphic sexuality are
interspersed with static shots of quiet contemplation, shattered by
voice-overs in which Marie ruminates about her dissatisfaction with life.
Were the conversation about, say, actuarial tables, Romance would be
pretty hard to take. But because it's about sex, the abundance of silence
and stillness holds a fascination. And much of what Breillat has to say,
via the (very) brave young actress Ducey and their mutual character Marie,
is boldly intriguing.
A few moments stand out. Marie holds a mirror to her vagina and her
face, and wonders if men are able to make a connection between the two, to
love them both equally. Similarly, Marie's boss jokes that most men
couldn't identify their own penis if they had to pick through a basketful
to find it. The two insights are brought together in a fantasy sequence:
Marie imagines a brothel where women are presented to men from the waist
down, only to be ravaged truly anonymously.
All of this has to do with the three-way disconnection between human
intellect, emotion, and desire. But if Romance comes off more as an
admirable, hard-to-like "think piece" than a gut-wrenching emotional
powerhouse, blame Breillat's own disconnection. The writer-director never
articulates fully whether her film is an essay on sexuality or a narrow
character study. The main problem is that Breillat never explains Marie's
boyfriend's sudden disinterest in sex, which makes what follows all the
harder to understand.
Whatever its flaws, Romance is a thought-provoking and often
upsetting film, with a high degree of artistic merit. And while film fans
in other major cities are free to love it or hate it, the large number of
cinephiles in Music City will have to table their debate until next year's
inevitable video release. How ridiculous is it that in a city with "The
World's Largest Adult Bookstore," where just about every downtown corner
houses a strip club or massage parlor, a serious look at sexuality is all
but shut out? Perhaps it's just a reflection of our nation at large, where
jokes on TV are getting smuttier and smuttier, but we can't see the uncut
Eyes Wide Shut. We push the envelope when it comes to making fun of
sex, but not when trying to understand it.