U.S. Marshals

Nashville Scene

DIRECTED BY: Stuart Baird

REVIEWED: 03-23-98

U.S. Marshals was destined to be a footnote to cinema history even before the film was shot; 10 years hence, someone will look up The Fugitive in a video guide and read the words "spawned an unsuccessful sequel, based on the Tommy Lee Jones character." Granted, Jones' part in The Fugitive--as Harrison Ford's dogged pursuer Lieutenant Gerard--was a highlight in a film full of highlights. But does he warrant a movie of his own?

Not really. Ancillary characters are in a story for a reason, to bring color and flash in short bursts. As exciting as Gerard and his staff of lawmen were in The Fugitive, there's something curiously ordinary about these folks as the subject of a feature. A team of federal cops catching crooks is the stuff of weekly TV shows, not motion-picture spectaculars.

The plot of U.S. Marshals is modified only slightly from its predecessor. Wesley Snipes plays a man incarcerated for a frame-up crime. During a "routine prison transfer"--is there any other kind in the movies?--a planeful of convicts goes down, and Snipes makes his escape. Jones is on the same plane, and he takes the con's flight personally. The marshals are called in, along with a special government operative (played by Robert Downey Jr., on loan from his own "routine prison transfer").

As in The Fugitive, there are close shaves and double-crosses and the occasional eye-popping stunt, but this time out, the load is unbalanced. Snipes' fugitive never develops into a recognizable person with real emotions. We never feel his panic. Instead, we're immersed in the hyperdrive rattle of Jones' dialogue, and the quick leaps of logic made by him and his fellow cops.

In fact, U.S. Marshals might've made a fine police procedural, if its plot twists weren't so obvious, and if it didn't carom off at impossible angles. Even the opening crash lacks the heat of realism--when the plane dives suddenly, no one hits the ceiling, and when the plane taxis down a makeshift highway landing strip, its wing strikes several telephone poles without sending the jet careening. Director Stuart Baird never convinces us that there's an original thinker or a vivid imagination behind the camera lens: A plane crash is a plane crash, and a chase is a chase.

This was never the case with The Fugitive, which had the audience so fully engaged in the twin obsessions of Ford and Jones that we didn't even mind the occasional awkward special effect. This point has been made before in these pages, but I'll beat a dead horse yet again: If the only reason to make a sequel is to repeat the bits that worked the first time and hope that the money falls the same way, then filmmakers shouldn't bother. It cheapens the memory of a good movie to make a fuzzy copy with the same materials. It's like a magician repeating a trick clumsily, so that we can see the coin going up his sleeve.

--Noel Murray

Full Length Reviews
U.S. Marshals
U.S. Marshals

Capsule Reviews
U.S. Marshals
U.S. Marshals

Other Films by Stuart Baird
Executive Decision

Film Vault Suggested Links
Smilla's Sense of Snow
Tomorrow Never Dies
Breakdown

Related Merchandise
Search for related videos at Reel.com
Search for more by Stuart Baird at Reel.com
Search for related books at Amazon.com
Search for related music at Amazon.com

Rate this Film
If you don't want to vote on a film yet, and would like to know how others voted, leave the rating selection as "Vote Here" and then click the Cast Vote button.