At a pivotal moment in Todd Haynes' Velvet Goldmine, a glam-rock
idol named Brian Slade (Jonathan Rhys Meyers) appears at a televised press
conference and declares his bisexuality. Watching at home, a closeted teen
leaps to his feet and shouts, "That's me!" There are about a dozen moments
in Velvet Goldmine, an audacious and exhilarating exploration of
image, celebrity, and the need to belong, that made me feel like doing the
same.
I didn't attend a rock concert until I was 18 years old, but I've never
forgotten the sensation of walking into a mobbed Municipal Auditorium and
feeling that I'd found a brotherhood that was always waiting for me.
Velvet Goldmine is an elegy for the moment in every pop-conscious
teen's life when he finds the music that speaks to, and for, him. It's also
the most original movie musical since Pennies from Heaven--a
delirious, excessive meditation on the ephemerality of pop, beauty, and
youth.
At its most basic (and silliest) level, Velvet Goldmine is a
mystery set against the rise and fall of glam rock in early-'70s London. In
the opening credits, a shot of glam kids on the prowl captures the
giddiness of fandom as brazenly as the opening of A Hard Day's
Night. Then Brian Slade, the glitter-rock superstar (all resemblances
to David Bowie purely coincidental), goes down onstage in a blast of
gunfire. The film burns up in the projector, and Slade's image melts into
the void; the next thing we see is New York in 1984, a place dominated by a
Reagan-like authoritarian and bland vanilla hegemony.
A British reporter, Arthur Stuart (Christian Bale) is assigned to find
out what really happened to Brian Slade after his "assassination" 10 years
before. The search leads to Slade's abandoned manager (Michael Feast), the
singer's embittered ex-wife (Toni Collette), and Curt Wild (Ewan McGregor),
the mascara'ed American proto-punk whose act was liberally borrowed by
Slade--and who shares a long-forgotten link to the investigator. The
further Arthur burrows into the enigma of the fallen idol, the more
fragmented his sense of the singer's identity becomes. Instead, it's his
own buried past that emerges from the shadows.
The movie bobs and weaves between Slade's rise to stardom and Arthur's
recovered memories of the joy and acceptance he felt as a glam groupie.
Along the way, Haynes' script plays amusing roman ˆ clef games with
glam history. Curt Wild, enacted with exhibitionist fervor and disarming
tenderness by McGregor, serves double duty as Iggy Pop and The New York
Dolls' David Johansen; Eddie Izzard plays Slade's manager as a thuggish
amalgam of Bowie's handler Tony DeFries and the Dolls' Malcolm McLaren.
Similarly, the delicious soundtrack mixes pitch-perfect Ziggy Stardust
knock-offs--commissioned from Shudder to Think, Grant Lee Buffalo, and
others--with swanky glam artifacts like Lou Reed's "Satellite of Love."
Whatever the closing disclaimer says, the relation to actual music and
musicians adds to the movie's epic you-are-there quality.
Despite his teasing nods to rockumentary, however, Haynes' telling of
the tale is anything but straightforward. When the story isn't progressing
through inventive mock video clips or fake newscasts, the characters dress
in circus garb and express themselves in Oscar Wilde's epigrams. Haynes
takes his cues as writer and director from the exuberant artifice in the
music: He matches the music-hall bounce of Slade's songs with snowstorms of
feathers and glitter, Mlies-like camera tricks, and sudden zooms and
speeded-up montages that scream end-of-the-'60s mod. Glam music and sex are
inextricable here.
But Todd Haynes isn't a pop scold, and his affection for the '70s'
happy-face hedonism gives Velvet Goldmine its trippy poignancy.
Unlike the makers of The Ice Storm, The People vs. Larry
Flynt, and the rest of the recent we-come-to-bury-the-'70s subgenre,
Haynes sees the decade as a triumph--a moment when queer culture subverted
the mainstream. Velvet Goldmine is the first American movie in years
that treats the sexual revolution as a victory, and a battle worth
rejoining.
Haynes first won notoriety with Superstar, his 1987 film that
reenacted the life of the late Karen Carpenter entirely with Barbie dolls.
(The cruel aptness of the metaphor wasn't lost on Richard Carpenter, who
successfully blocked the film from being shown.) Haynes followed that with
Poison, a 1991 drama that explored what it means to be ghettoized
for sexual preference. Here, the director expressed his solidarity with
anyone who dared to be an outsider--as he did with subtle but scalding
sarcasm in Safe, his horror movie about the consequences of denying
all pleasure and stimuli to further the illusion of security. Velvet
Goldmine is anything but Safe: It's an immersion in sensation,
especially the sense of liberation found in discovering you're not a freak
for dressing, acting, or loving differently.
For Velvet Goldmine, Haynes cheekily borrows the basic structure
of Citizen Kane, from the fake-documentary opening to the interview
flashbacks. There is a Rosebud, a saucer-shaped pin handed down from aliens
(!) to Oscar Wilde (!!!) to a succession of rogue dandies. There is a Jed
Leland figure, a coke-dusted Xanadu, even an amusing recreation of Susan
Kane's first appearance in her deserted nightclub. Yet this isn't smart-ass
movie geekery, even if Haynes indulges himself with references to
everything from Performance to The Umbrellas of Cherbourg.
Kane, after all, searches a famous man's past for the human being
buried in the hype. In the end, though, Charles Foster Kane the media
invention lives on, and the man himself remains a cipher. Scratch the
surface of any pop idol, Haynes suggests, and you wind up with the same
story of self-invention.
Only there's no more meaning to Brian Slade than the personae he adopts
and discards like feather boas. "A man's life is his image," says a Haynes
spokesman, knowing full well that in rock 'n' roll the opposite is equally
true: Celebrity lasts only as long as a performer can cloak himself in a
billboard-sized myth, onto which fans can project their own desires for
escape and transcendence. Small wonder the other fictional touchstone of
this universe is Dorian Gray--except here it's the portrait that remains
ageless.
I don't know how Velvet Goldmine would've affected me if I
weren't a downside-of-30 rock 'n' roll junkie feeling a wistful
disconnection from youth culture. But Haynes' glam-rock fantasia captures
not only the rush of discovery, but the inevitable end that's part of pop's
flickering life. Maybe that's why his closing image is so haunting and so
just: a rocker's declaration to fade away never, fading away.