THERE'S BEEN A GLUT of costume movies recently, most of
them about the British--Restoration, Sense And Sensibility,
Persuasion, Carrington and now Angels and Insects,
a romantic drama about a wealthy English family set in Victorian
times.
These films have so much in common (all of them have a difficult
romance at their center), and have been released so close together
that they're practically begging to have a generalization made
about them. So here goes: All these period films have at their
core a nostalgia for a sense of order and social decorum, especially
in the bedroom. All are fascinated with the restrictions and brittleness
that governed boy/girl coupling in the 19th century. Their politics,
submerged under hoop skirts, are reactionary--showing a longing
for simpler times when the rules of gender and class were sharply
delineated and something as minor as weeping at the ball was considered
a disruptive act.
Much as I liked some of these films (especially Sense and
Sensibility), I can't help but be suspicious of this trend
as a whole. These movies, which yearn for the past and consistently
portray women as passive, homosexuals (if shown at all) as outsiders,
and white men as being the only people who can move through the
world freely, share more than a few themes with the campaign rhetoric
of Pat Buchanan.
Which is why Angels and Insects is refreshing. Of the
group, it's by far the most subversive. It takes the refrains
of helpless, victimized women, strong men, and rigid class rules
and distorts them. Nothing is quite as it seems in this movie,
and a sense of creeping rot pervades the calm surface of Victorian
society.
The story centers around the Alabaster family, a clan of filthy-rich
blondes living in a huge country house. There are two beautiful
grown-up daughters, a snotty son, a father who spends his idle
days studying natural history, and an enormously fat mother. Into
this group steps William Adamson (Mark Rylance), a young naturalist
who has just returned from a dangerous butterfly hunting trip
in the Amazon. Unfortunately, he's lost all of his notes and specimens
in a shipwreck and in his penniless state must rely on the generosity
of the Alabasters.
And let's not forget the romance. William is immediately taken
with the beautiful and mysterious Eugenia (Patsy Kensit), the
eldest Alabaster daughter. Eugenia spends most of her time weeping
and acting tragic. The two don't have much in common. William
seems to regard her as another beautiful specimen to add to his
collection, and despite the fact that he's very poor, he manages
to persuade her to marry him.
It's clear from the glum music and strange costumes (weird hoop
skirts in painfully bright colors), not to mention the strange
behavior of the servants, that something is wrong in the Alabaster
house, but what is wrong is not made explicit for quite
a while. Angels is based on a contemporary novel by A.S.
Byatt, and though the setting is Victorian, the plot twists turn
out to be very 20th-century. I won't give it away (though the
preview does), but I will say the concerns of the movie are largely
erotic.
William is a naturalist, and much of the film is taken up by
his study of insects. Some of the most fascinating shots are close-ups
of bugs--a moth emerging from a pupae, a bucketful of beetles,
a colony of ants. The crawly fecundity of the insect world stands
in stark contrast to the repression of Victorian society; but
then, maybe they do have something in common. The Alabaster family
seems to be harboring some dark secret, like a centipede hiding
under a rock.
Angels and Insects works best when it deals in innuendo
and conjecture. As in director Philip Haas' last movie, The
Music of Chance (which was terrific), a fascinating sense
of unspoken desire floats through this movie. The family is so
strange and wooden (they do not use contractions), the romance
between William and Eugenia so distant and tense, that the simple
psychological resolution we get is disappointing. The film's main
strengths are its skewed sense of tension and literary sensibilities.
When the tension is resolved by a plot twist that will be familiar
to many readers of contemporary fiction, Angels and Insects
runs out of steam. Without a dirty little secret lurking (which,
like the transvestite in the Crying Game, hardly came as
a surprise), the film seems empty.