WHAT IS IT about foreign settings that make youthful romances
work so much more effectively than they would on the home front?
Obviously the settings themselves are romantic, but the real appeal
lies in our predisposition towards adoring people from faraway
lands--people with accents. Perhaps due to their differences,
foreign characters remind us less of our own awkward youths than
of idealized notions of what youth and innocence should
be.
That was certainly the case with Gregory's Girl (from
Scotland) and The Year My Voice Broke (from Australia),
where sentiments that might otherwise sound dorky came across
as endearing when expressed by British-voiced protagonists. Now
it proves to be the case with Circle of Friends, a coming-of-age
love story set in sunny, green Ireland. Imagine an American movie
where a horny young male tries to convince his girlfriend to sleep
with him by saying, "I could go to 7-11 and get some condoms."
Not too appealing, right? But what if it's 1957 Dublin, and that
the same male lead has a soft-toned accent in which he sweetly
proposes, "I could buy fresh leathers"? Now that's romantic.
Circle of Friends makes full use of its environment and
time period, and that's important since the story follows such
a standard path. It's your usual girl-meets-boy, girl-loses-boy,
and girl-wins-boy-back tale, with a few tragic complications thrown
in for good measure. You can see each new development coming long
before it arrives, but as directed by Pat O'Connor (who sounds
a bit Irish) the film's commitment to its cause keeps the whole
enterprise vibrant and new.
Benny (Minnie Driver) is the film's main character. She's a shy
lass just starting her freshman year at Trinity College, along
with her friends Eve (Geraldine O'Rawe) and the sultry Nan (Saffron
Burrows, who appears to have stolen Stockard Channing's eyes).
On the first day of school, Benny finds herself instantly attracted
to the blue-eyed, golden-haired Jack (Chris O'Donnell), a rugby
player and all-around popular fellow with a smile that could melt
glass. And herein lies the first of the story's predicaments:
Benny is large. She's not necessarily fat, but with her wide face
and thick build, she's an unlikely match for the best-looking
guy on campus.
What's worse, Benny's potential social life is stunted by the
fact that at the end of every day she has to endure a long, lonely
bus ride to the outlying village where her protective parents
reside. Though loving, her mom and pop have no clue what Benny
wants, and they presumptuously set her up with the weasely Sean,
who has fooled Benny's father into letting him become a business
partner and "one of the family." Sean will hereby be
referred to as The Creepy Guy, because with his devious eyes,
reptilian nostrils and slicked hair he comes across as an ungodly
blend of Eddie Haskell, Pee Wee Herman and Dracula. Though The
Creepy Guy is the most unrealistic presence in Circle of Friends,
he's also the most memorable, and don't be surprised if you hear
"Sssss" sounds in the theater whenever he comes around.
Benny is rightfully disgusted by his advances, one of which involves
groping her breast in a movie theater and then pretending nothing
happened.
Once Circle of Friends establishes this cruel environment
for its heroine, the movie sets about the task of bringing her
together with Jack, who turns out to be a true prize: a boyfriend
who has no trouble seeing beyond Benny's physical imperfection
to the beauty inside. Their courtship runs from cute to comic,
starting with knowing glances in a classroom and culminating with
a makeout session in which the two actors shout "Jack!",
"Benny!", "Jack!", "Benny!" (a joke
that seemed to be lost on much of the audience).
This is by all means a female fantasy movie, but it's a fantasy
you can believe in thanks to Minnie Driver's consistently winning
performance. Through the simplest of expressions Driver shows
us a strong, spirited person who is undeniably worthy of love.
O'Donnell's performance is a bit weaker--he's not a polished actor,
and he can't quite get that Irish accent down--but there's no
denying his effectiveness. And I couldn't help admiring what a
smart career move O'Donnell has made by appearing in this small
picture, offsetting his larger, dumber roles such as the bland
lead in The Three Musketeers or Robin in this summer's
Batman flick.
There isn't much to be said about Circle of Friends' second
half, which includes misunderstandings, errors of judgment, tragedy
and the continued scheming of The Creepy Guy. What is more important
to note is what a nice message Circle of Friends sends
out to its female audience. Here's a heroine who succeeds by virtue
of simply sticking to her convictions. She doesn't make a fool
out of herself, and she doesn't play into lies, manipulations
or the pressure to have sex (she waits until she's damn sure it's
what she wants). Contrast that with Muriel's Wedding, which
has almost the opposite storyline: an overweight heroine who lies
to herself and accepts compromising positions throughout the entire
picture. These two films are practically bookends, with Muriel's
Wedding on the gaudy, purposely obnoxious Australian side
and Circle of Friends on the charming, sturdy-willed Irish
side. As coming-of-age stories go, you can't get a more globally
diverse--and appealing--selection than that.