JEAN-LUC GODARD once said that film history was the history
of boys photographing girls. According to Mark Rappaport, the
acclaimed filmmaker who made 1992's Rock Hudson's Home Movies
among other films, the tragic history of actress Jean Seberg was
also shaped (and perhaps deformed) by the cool gaze of a camera
standing in for the glance of the male eye.
Seberg was chosen by Otto Preminger (who by the way was famously
mean) to play the role of Joan of Arc in his ill-conceived Saint
Joan, after an exhaustive and well-publicized star search.
At the time, Seberg was 17 years old and had acted mainly in high
school plays. Rappaport, who structures From the Journals of
Jean Seberg as a fictionalized biography centering on clips
from Seberg's films, has found an amazing clip which seems to
be from her screen test with Preminger. In it, she appears as
a pretty teenager who tilts her head and says she wants "very
much to be an actress." Her naiveté is thick enough
to cut with a knife, as is her ambition, making what follows all
the more tragic: After a huge amount of publicity for the times,
Preminger's Saint Joan flopped, and all critics agreed
that Seberg was terrible.
A wash-up at 18, Seberg's career was resurrected several years
later by the French new wave filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard, who cast
her as the female lead in Breathless. Seberg became famous
for a time in Europe, and French women began to cut their hair
in her style. Rappaport chronicles these ups and downs with a
technique that seems a bit strange at first: He strings clips
from Seberg's films alongside extensive clips from other films
of the time, all narrated by Mary Beth Hurt, who appears occasionally
playing a wiser, ghostly version of Seberg herself.
Hurt's narration is at times witty, at times gossipy, and usually
permeated by the vocabulary of academic film criticism. Seberg
herself was certainly no graduate student, and the effect of this
rather in-depth analysis coming out of her mouth is a bit disconcerting.
What Hurt as Seberg has to say, on the other hand, is downright
interesting. She speaks about the conditions of film production
before anyone had ever heard of feminism, and how these conditions
almost as a matter of course were degrading for actresses. The
careers of Seberg as well as Jane Fonda and Vanessa Redgrave are
discussed at length, complete with supporting film clips.
From the Journals of Jean Seberg has the character, at
times, of a scholarly essay, but with one major difference: All
of Rappaport's points are illustrated by carefully chosen, and
sometimes quite funny, scenes from old movies. Like Rock Hudson's
Home Movies, which aimed to expose the personal life of Rock
Hudson by looking carefully at his Hollywood movies, From the
Journals of Jean Seberg also proposes to excavate the "inner"
Seberg by looking at the very public face of the films she made
in Hollywood and Europe. In this Rappaport has put forth a risky
thesis--as anyone who has tried to illuminate their family background
with photographs may have found--pictures are extremely slippery
in their meaning. Rappaport himself devotes a rather long portion
of From the Journals to explaining the Kuleshov effect,
an early film experiment that says, basically, that a picture
tends to mean whatever someone says it means.
What Rappaport says the clips from Seberg's film reveal is a
steady decline, on Seberg's part, from enthusiasm and innocence
to a sad, masochistic, selfless image of a woman who has somehow
given the most vital part of herself away to the camera. I tend
to believe this is a romanticized view of Seberg's decline, though
some of the points Rappaport makes are trenchant and fascinating.
Why, for example, did so many actresses, including Seberg, end
up making films for their director/husbands which depicted them
as sluts, whores, or nymphomaniacs? Rappaport does a fine job
of exposing what was, in the 1960s, the unexplored fear of women
and their sexuality that permeated movies.
Whether it was due to a series of bad roles and exploitation,
as Rappaport seems to imply, or a more personal sense of disappointment
that the camera couldn't capture, Seberg's life went into a slide
in the '70s. After a period of political activism and involvement
with the Black Panthers (including hiding guns in her house),
Seberg found herself the target of intense and paranoid FBI scrutiny.
Her popularity suffered, and Seberg was found dead in a Paris
suburb, an apparent suicide, before her 40th birthday.