LET'S FACE IT, kids' movies are for kids. An hour and a
half of whimsy may delight a 10-year-old to death, but her grown-up
escort is bound to get a little restless. James and the Giant
Peach is a case in point: This stop-motion animated version
of Roald Dahl's classic children's story is well-paced, imaginative
and full of exciting visual tidbits. The animation alone is so
clever that it's hard not be impressed. And yet, each time the
giant insects broke into song, I could feel the adults in the
audience cringe, as we all thought in unison: God no, not a
song.
They sing. Giant insects sing perky songs. To give some credit
where it's due, the score, by Randy Newman, is far more engaging
than that of The Nightmare Before Christmas, the previous
film from the same production team of Tim Burton and Henry Selick.
In fact, James and the Giant Peach is much more sophisticated
and entertaining than Nightmare, though it's no Babe--in
other words, there's not an adult-level story lurking inside the
one for children.
Or is there? I happened to see James and the Giant Peach
with a Marxist friend, who proposed a remarkably coherent political
interpretation of the film. Surprisingly, the trajectory of the
plot fits quite neatly inside Marxist theory. Yes, this story
of an orphan who journeys across the ocean in the belly of a large
fruit is in fact a parable of workers coming to consciousness
and power.
At the beginning of the movie, James lives quite happily in a
cottage with his parents. None of them are conventionally employed,
and they seem to exist in an ideal pre-history when workers are
at one with the product of their labor. Then, disaster strikes,
in the form of a rhino, which could only represent the advent
of industrialization. After the rhino (and the death of his parents),
James is forced to live with his evil aunts, Spiker and Sponge.
Spiker and Sponge torture and misuse the boy. He is forced to
toil while they kick back and sip beverages. Obviously, James
has come to represent the exploited worker who creates value that
will be enjoyed by idle property owners, but never by him. Poor
James! Nobody loves him.
Eventually though, James' work begins, quite literally, to
bear fruit. With the help of a little magic, James makes a giant
peach grow on his aunt's property. The "peach" is in
fact the metaphorical representation of the surplus value created
by his tireless labor. I mean, what represents overabundance better
than a 20-foot peach? Immediately, his aunts, greedy capitalists
that they are, claim ownership of the fuzzy behemoth and try to
exploit it for big bucks. But James knows what all good Marxists
know: The peach doesn't belong to the aunts simply because it
grew on their property. It exists to be shared among those who
made it and those who use it, which happens to be James, along
with a group of grossly enlarged bugs.
James and the insects seize the fruit for themselves. Workers
of the world, unite! Mr. Centipede gnaws through the stem of the
peach and it rolls down a hill. It rolls--this is it--the
revolution! It tumbles down the hill, crushing Spiker and Sponge,
the heartless profiteers, because, after all, history is an unstoppable
force. Then James and the bugs (garden pests swollen by the same
steroid-magic that struck the peach) voyage across the ocean in
a post-revolutionary state. Their task at this point is difficult
and large: They must learn to govern themselves without falling
back on the cruel hierarchical
system that caused them such anguish in the first place.
The road is long. (It's not a road, actually, they're inside
a peach being pulled by a flock of seagulls, but anyway). They
must contend with many obstacles, including a huge, mechanized
shark (representing, once again, the cruel forces of industrialization,
as well as being some of the coolest animation in the movie).
In the face of such troubles, do they elect one of their members
to be a leader? Do they fall prey to the fascistic longings of
a power-mad grasshopper? No! They work together, each according
to his ability--in a collective, so to speak. They even sing a
little song about it. And as a collective, they are able to achieve
their goals and retain a sense of self-worth and social connectedness.
At last, they chart a course for New York, where they will share
the excess peachflesh with the masses. The revolution has gone
international!