THERE IS A scene about two-thirds of the way through Lone
Star, John Sayles' wonderfully intricate tale of life in a
Texas border town, that leaves the moviegoer with a deep sense
of melancholy.
Frontera town sheriff Sam Deeds (Chris Cooper) has gone to see
his ex-wife (Frances McDormand), who's more than a little nutty
even when she's on medication. She's wearing a Dallas Cowboys
jersey, a Houston Oilers hat, and watching a tape of a Texas A&M
football game. In the middle of the conversation, she asks in
all sincerity if he watched the recent NFL draft.
When he says no, she launches into an animated speech about how
teams have prospective players tested, followed, interviewed--everything
short of taking stool samples. She then pauses and adds, "That's
a lot more than any regular people does when choosing the person
they're going to marry and spend the rest of their life with."
That one little moment provides more insight into the human condition
than all of the summer blockbusters put together, all of the stunt-and-special-effects
orgies for which you offered up your money to the god of overpriced
popcorn. This leaves you a little bit sad for the current state
of American filmmaking--stale and shallow and aimed with laser
precision to stop at the optic nerve and not enter the brain.
It leaves you a little bit more sad that the google-plexes can't
free up even one screen for a film like this, one brimming with
ideas, emotions and nuances. If they could, maybe someone would
get frustrated at not being able to get in to see Independence
Day and "settle" for a seat in half-empty Lone
Star, where they would delight in the almost-lost art of story
telling.
Instead, Sayles' epic, wrapped around a 40-year-old murder mystery,
will have a quiet run at The Loft, where the average moviegoer
will pass it off as one of those "art-house" things
destined to slip quietly into video-dom. Sayles, then, is left
to preach to the converted, those of us who loved the wry politics
of The Brother From Another Planet, the wrenching realism
of Matewan and the clever retelling of the Black Sox scandal
in Eight Men Out.
Lone Star is not one story told well, but several
told exceedingly well. Besides the aforementioned murder mystery,
it offers up a knowing look at ethnic tension between Anglos and
Hispanics, a sly take on small-town politics, with even a love
story thrown in--one that is satisfying in its passion and clever
in its clumsiness.
Writer-director-editor Sayles takes his time and gets everything
right. He invests his characters with an all-too-rare depth and
complexity, marked by the actors' singularly focused Oscar-winning
performances. And he manages to do so with 10 or 12 characters,
not just one.
Every character in this movie is like someone we've known, someone
we've heard about, or someone we'd like to be. Sayles takes these
characters and weaves a bold multi-ethnic tapestry full of bitter
divisions and small compromises, a fabric torn by bitterness
but held together by threads of humanity. The Anglo-Hispanic tableau
is richly drawn and would be completely satisfying on its own,
but Sayles ups the ante by adding another ethnic group to the
mix, some African-Americans tied socially and economically to
the area by the nearby Army base. He deftly avoids the use of
generalizations or false integrity--two equally annoying Hollywood
tendencies--instead allowing his story to unfold naturally.
The plot (or at least the main plot) of this film, told in seamless
flashbacks, involves the discovery of some skeletal remains in
the desert. Sam Deeds realizes almost immediately that it's probably
one-time sheriff Charley Wade (Kris Kristofferson), a crooked
and hateful man whose only consistency was that he mistreated
and stole from everyone equally. Wade went missing one night after
a verbal run-in with his deputy Buddy Deeds (Matthew McConaughey),
who succeeded him and became a town legend to everyone but his
son, who doesn't even try to live up to his dad's reputation.
The townspeople didn't much care what happened to Wade; they
were just glad that he was gone. Now that his bones have turned
up, Sam must attempt to solve the crime, even though all clues
point to Buddy, who was everything to the town and its people
that Wade hadn't been.
Along the way, he rekindles a romance with a local schoolteacher
(Elizabeth Pena), who's dealing with rebellious kids at home,
rednecks who want the Davy Crockett history of Texas taught exclusively,
and a widowed mother (Miriam Colon) who runs her restaurant with
an iron fist and insists that everyone speak English around her,
even though she came across the river the same way everybody else
did.
The mystery ties everything together and its conclusion is inventive,
but by the time we get there, we care so much about all of the
characters we're glad Wade is gone, too, and we don't much care
who did him. Sayles wraps up the mystery, then adds an Omigod!
kicker at the end that will leave you slack-jawed till the middle
of next week.
To say that this is the best movie thus far this year is to damn
it with extremely faint praise. It's an absolute Godsend, reinstilling
the movies with hope and creativity and the ability to entertain,
enlighten and move us, all at the same time.
This is a great movie, one which will be long gone by Labor Day.
Don't let it pass by unnoticed.