THE PRIMAVERA FILM Festival continues this weekend with a presentation
of the 1996 documentary Paris Was A Woman, downtown at
The Screening Room. It's hard to think of a more apt selection
to celebrate the participation of women in the arts than this
documentary, mostly assembled from archival footage, that chronicles
the ground-breaking achievements of artists and writers in Paris
between the wars. The work and lives of Gertrude Stein, Colette,
and Romaine Brooks, among others, are described through photographs
and by people who knew them. Interviews with surviving friends
(including Berthe Cleyrergue, housekeeper to poet Natalie Barney,
who reports that Alice B. Toklas was "very pleasant")
are intercut with archival footage and the stray comment from
an academic or two to produce an affectionate, thoughtful fanletter
to a spirited bunch of free-thinkers in a time when women were
not encouraged to think much at all.
Director Greta Schiller has been interested, throughout her career,
in making documentaries composed of archival footage that investigate
lost or overlooked aspects of history (her other films include
Before Stonewall and Sweethearts of Rhythm, the
story of an all-female, interracial jazz band from the '40s).
Together with writer and historian Andrea Weiss, she's produced
a film about one of the most discussed and investigated periods
of literary history--the '20s, the period of "the lost generation."
("They didn't seem lost at all," comments Janet Flanner,
for years the New Yorker's Paris corespondent. "They
knew exactly where they were going--straight to Paris.")
By focusing on the work and lives of the female artists and intellectuals
drawn to Paris in the '20s, Schiller and Weiss have produced a
film that seriously considers the contribution of women to Modernism,
a movement mostly dominated by men.
American artists, male and female, were drawn to Paris by the
strength of the dollar between the wars, the availability of good
food and wine (especially alluring during Prohibition), and by
its reputation as a haven for artists. But women, in particular,
were attracted to Paris because they believed it was a place where
they could live in whatever way they wished. Parisians were tolerant
(Gertrude Stein said they were busy living their lives so that
she was free to live hers), and those women who wished to live
in a free and unconventional manner seemed to find the place irresistible.
Most of the women Schiller tracks in her documentary were lesbians;
most were also displaced Americans. Though Schiller may be guilty
of skewing her history a bit in favor of expatriate lesbians,
it's hard to fault her, since their stories are so interesting,
and their motivation for emigration to the Left Bank of Paris,
where unconventionality seems to have flourished in conservative
times, seems so clear.
Most famous of these expatriates was Gertrude Stein, who was
known at the time for her collection of modern art and weekly
salons. Stein served as mentor for Picasso, Hemingway and Sherwood
Anderson, influencing their work heavily even as her own writing
remained unknown. If Gertrude Stein were alive today, she would
probably be some sort of major media figure--her presence, even
on the scratchy home movies that Schiller unearthed, is magnetic.
With her cropped hair, deep voice and matronly dresses, Stein
is the most seductive presence in the film, spinning off quotable
lines and tramping through the countryside with her "great
companion," Alice B. Toklas.
Also featured in the film is Sylvia Beach, owner of Shakespeare
and Co., a bookstore that became the center of expatriate intellectual
culture at the time. Schiller has located some great black-and-white
footage of Beach taken in the '60s, where she breezily recounts
her early literary adventures, including befriending the young
Hemingway, who insisted on taking her to sporting events. Beach
championed the work of James Joyce and published Ulysses
when no one else would touch it. (It was considered obscene.)
Later, Joyce broke their contract and sold the rights to Random
House without giving Beach a penny.
Other, lesser-known artists like the tortured Djuna Barnes and
the heiress/poet Natalie Clifford Barney are given serious attention
in this film, along with photographer Gisele Freund and painter
Marie Laurencin.
The coming of World War II quashed the spirit of Paris' community
of artists, but Greta Schiller's film presents a fine chronicle
of those who once considered the city neither a mistress nor a
muse, but a haven where they were free to think and work.